THE BEST BREAKFAST CEREALS FOR YOUR HEALTH – AND THE ONES TO AVOID
Take a walk along the cereal aisle of the supermarket and you would think it was the epicentre of a wholesome diet. The garish packaging jostles for attention with comforting claims: High in fibre from whole grains! Fuels a healthy gut! Nine vitamins and minerals! Supporting your family’s health! On your side! Support healthy bones! Reduce tiredness and fatigue!
Another slogan that could be added is: Low risk of injury! The same can’t be said for another breakfast favourite, the avocado. The Royal Society of the Prevention of Accidents warned last week that “avocado hand” – when people slice into their hand while halving or de-stoning the fruit – is sending people to A&E.
It led Alan Titchmarsh, the nation’s most famous gardener, to proclaim: “There is a simple solution to avoiding injury when removing the stone from an avocado: don’t eat them.” In a letter to The Times, argued: “There’s a lot to be said for Cornflakes, Weetabix and Shreddies.”
However, the reality is that their health credentials are debatable, with the contents of these boxes frequently containing high amounts of sugar, salt and ultra-processed ingredients.
There are also concerns over fortification – those “with nine vitamins and minerals” claims. Some may be a good thing, for example vitamin D, which we are in short supply of in the winter months. But as Marion Nestle, a professor of nutrition at New York University, points out in her book, Food Politics, “the increasingly common addition of vitamins and minerals” is unlikely to improve our health and “raises concerns about the possible hazards of too much of a good thing”.
Let’s not tar all cereal with the same brush, though. There are cereals out there that do provide a decent start to the day. And there’s no doubt they provide a quick fix. The best provide a good source of fibre and complex, slow release carbohydrate. So don’t be a cereal killer: just pick and choose a wholesome option whose claims actually do stack up.
Astonishingly high in sugar and protein, although both these figures are skewed as there’s milk powder in already. Fair on fibre (3.6g) and contains flavouring and anticaking agent, so it’s ultra-processed.
Breakfast pot noodle style: just fill up from the kettle. The result is gluey and wildly sweet and tastes weirdly of caramel flavouring rather than golden syrup. Grim.
Yellow on the traffic light system for sugar (5.3g per 30g serving), and no great shakes for protein and fibre, and plenty of UPF ingredients including palm oil, antioxidant and colouring.
Sweet, crisp and airy with a caramel nuttiness. Slight grit of fibre in there but not enough to put off the kids, so it might be a gateway to higher fibre cereals. But it doesn’t seem very filling.
Fair on fibre (3.8g per two biscuit serving) and protein, not much sugar. But it contains malted barley extract, which Van Tulleken says is a flavour enhancer and puts these in the UPF category.
Gently malty and biscuity with the crispness quickly dissipating into mush. On the bland side. The packet suggests adding berries and seeds which seems like a good idea both for flavour and nutrition.
Added wheat gluten, a complete protein, brings this up to 7.6g per two biscuit serving. It has similar levels to regular Weetabix for sugar and fibre, as well as that UPF malted barley extract.
The texture is different – there are crunchy, nubbly bits that are reminiscent of Grape Nuts, and a faint, pleasant bitterness which may be down to some cocoa powder in the mix. I prefer these to the regular Weetabix.
Low in fibre, just 0.9g per 30g serving, 2.1g of protein and 2.4g of sugar. Contains barley malt extract, a UPF ingredient.
Gently sweet, almost honeyed, malty with a hint of bitter flavours which amplify the taste of the milk – no wonder cereal milk is a thing. Crisp, but turning soggy in about three minutes. Not filling.
For a cereal that sells itself as fibre-rich, 3.6g per 40g portion is disappointing. There’s a lot of sugar, although this will be partly down to the dried fruit. Contains barley malt extract so it’s ultra-processed.
Generously packed with fruit and coconut, and crisp sweet flakes that go soggy in three minutes. Very small official portion though (40g is just 100ml or half a teacupful). You would pour much more.
6.3g of protein per 50g serving, which is a good amount, a respectable 3.7g of fibre and 3.6g of sugars (partly down to the dried fruit). No barley malt extract, but there’s fructose, which according to Sao Paulo University’s professor Carlos Monteiro, one of the people who first identified the dangers of ultra-processed foods, is a marker for UPF.
Toasty oat and seed flavour, but finely chopped, not in clumps like a traditional granola. Quite sweet, but wholesome, although an official 50g portion measures just 75ml. “You’ll find nature’s most nutritious ingredients inside our cereals,” says the pack, which feels hyperbolic – there’s no Brazil nuts, to start with.
4.3g of protein, 4g of fibre and 6.6g of sugar per 45g serving – all of it from the dried fruit. Nothing even vaguely ultra-processed among the ingredients.
The official portion of 45g measures just 60ml or 4tbsp, making it more of a topping than a cereal in its own right. Just as well, as it’s heavy going, with raw tasting oats, and I can’t find the Brazil nuts.
Predictably sugary and low on the good stuff, at 1.9g of protein, 1.1g of fibre and 5.1g of sugars per 30g serving. Contains barley malt extract and flavourings.
I’m completely disarmed by these. Sweet but not overly so and thanks to the bitterness of the cocoa they are actually quite sophisticated. But I’d still rather have them for pudding than breakfast.
A whopping 11g of sugar, a measly 0.8g of fibre and even with the peanuts the protein is only 1.8g per 30g portion. It also contains barley malt extract and is so sweet I can feel my gums receding in panic, like I’ve eaten a pack of chocolate hobnobs. Except chocolate hobnobs have less sugar. Lordy.
4.5g of sugars – on the high side. 2.4g of protein and 1.8g of fibre per 30g portion: I would like to see more of both in this “dieter’s” cereal. Contains barley malt extract, and a slightly higher fortification than other cereals.
There’s a lovely nubbly crunch to these lightly sweet flakes with a lingering malty aftertaste. They don’t go soggy as quickly as cornflakes, so there’s no need to bolt them.
A below average 2.4g of sugars, 2.1g of protein and just 0.9g of fibre per 30g portion. Contains barley malt extract.
Airy with a malty, toasty flavour, these go soggy very quickly. To be fair, they are not too sweet, but they aren’t filling either.
At last, a cereal with the right balance, just 0.4g of sugars, plus a decent 4.4g of protein (without milk) and 3.6g of fibre per 40g portion. Just oats in there, and simply rolled, so minimally processed, and the oats are good slow release carbs.
Cooks up to a simple breakfast, with a good nubbly texture. I like mine with a tiny pinch of salt.
*Above protein score is for a portion made with half milk, half water. Red (4.4g) without milk.
5g of sugar, 4.3g of protein and 4.8g of fibre per 40g portion. Contains barley malt extract – although the shape alone is an indicator these are highly processed.
Dear little bathmat-shaped pieces, very sweet and ultra malty, crunchy going soft within three minutes. Nice but very confected, like having digestives for breakfast.
Less than 0.5g of sugar, 4.4g of protein and 2.8g of fibre per 30g portion. Very respectable, and the only ingredient is wheat. Even if puffing said wheat would be hard to do at home, it’s relatively simple so these aren’t UPF.
Sadly these are chewy and dull, like tiny wotsits or polystyrene depending on your point of view. A bit of toasted wheat flavour in there – curiously nostalgic, but not delicious. Mind you, you get a big bowlful (250ml) for your 30g portion.
0.3g of sugar, 5.5g of fibre and 5.5g of protein per two biscuit portion, which is pretty hard to fault. Pure wheat, although I can’t imagine how these are made.
They taste wiry and tough, like I’ve fallen face down on a doormat, and very bland, with just a faint whiff of cardboard. The hair shirt of cereals.
Recommended
What eating bread really does to your body – and the healthiest supermarket loaves to buy
2025-03-11T08:55:07Z